OK, I'll Bite

Star Trek 35
IDW Publishing
Mike Johnson, writer
Tony Shasteen, artist

This issue is the first of a six-part story arc called "The Q Gambit," and I was nervous going into this issue. For starters, this would be the longest story arc so far attempted by this incarnation of Star Trek; most arcs were smaller two-issues tales, with an occasional four-issue miniseries tied to the two J.J. Abrams movies. Did this story really need to be six issues long?

And an even more basic questions was, should this story even be told at all? I like the character of Q, first introduced in "The Next Generation" continuity of "Star Trek," but a little Q goes a long way. He is a character that very easily could be overused or used incorrectly. Do we really need to impose him on the rebooted Trek universe, and if so, why at such an early point in time, as we humans measure it?

This creative team does an excellent job in this first installment answering those exact questions: why is Q in the rebooted universe and why is he showing up earlier in that universe than he did in the reality that preceded it?

It all goes back to the Trek fact that Vulcans live much longer than humans, and that Spock is still around and kicking during much of "The Next Generation" time span. Spock appeared in a number of TNG episodes, so it is canon that Spock and Q are contemporaries. I don't recall an instance where the two characters met in any TNG episode — or even in any of the licensed novels based on the Trek universe. But Spock and Q do meet and have a philosophical debate in the Alien Voices production of Star Trek: Spock Vs. Q. I'm not entirely sure if that audio-drama is considered canon or not, but as contemporaries, it is possible that Spock and Q could have met, even if said meeting has yet to be depicted.

So this series starts out in the original TNG continuity with Q popping onto the Enterprise to speak with now-Ambassador Jean-Luc Picard about their mutual acquaintance, Spock, in the aftermath of the events told in the first Abrams Trek film. To any of the contemporary people of the original Trek universe, Spock is presumed dead after he went back into the past in that film because he never returns to that timeline. But Q, being omniscient, knows all about the new timeline created by Spock's actions, along with the fact that Spock is alive and well in that altered timeline. Also, Q knows of some universe-ending event that will destroy that altered timeline. Q's visit to the Enterprise is to let Picard know that the Spock Picard knows is alive and well, but not for long, and to ask Picard's advice on whether or not he — Q — should intervene in this universe-ending event that threatens that other timeline. Picard, of course, comes down on the side of Q not interfering with any natural order of events, and Q, naturally, takes that as a challenge to do exactly what he wants anyway.

Thus, Q thrusts himself into the altered Trek timeline for perfectly valid reasons, at least as far as Q is concerned. And I would have to agree that his actions herein are quite consistent with his established character.

Mike Johnson is a regular on the IDW Trek titles and handles his duties with the usual spot-on characterizations and intelligent, griping writing that this series is known for. Tony Shasteen is a newcomer to the IDW Trek franchise and is praised in the back of the book in the newly launched letters page for his ability to capture the likenesses of the actors who portray the Trek characters on both big and small screens. The art on this Star Trek Ongoing series has been mostly good from the beginning with a variety of artists handling the illustration chores and handing in mostly good character likenesses. Shasteen's art in this issue seems a bit darker than is typical for this series; everyone's faces, clothing and backgrounds have a lot more shadowing than readers are used to. That in and of itself isn't a bad thing, but I wouldn't want to see the palette permanently shifted to such a degree when Trek is known for its generally positive, brighter future than other science fiction franchises portray. Some of Shasteen's panels also seem to sport pretty stiff characters as if he is relying too much on photo reference to capture those likenesses. Not every panel suffers in this way, but some that particuarly seem to scream for action do depict stiff figures at odd angles. It was enough to pull me out of the story a time or two.

Mostly though, I feel this story is in capable hands, and I'm anxious to see it play out over the next five issues.

Judge The Complete Story, Not A Piece Of It

Saucer Country Vols. 1 & 2: Run/The Reticulan Candidate
DC Vertigo
Paul Cornell, writer
Ryan Kelly, artist

Saucer Country has been on my radar from time to time over the last year or so since its debut in 2012. I was curious about it, but didn't know much about what to expect and had never picked up an issue. Then a few months ago, on a comics trip with my nephew, I found a good deal on the first trade and decided to take the plunge "down the rabbit hole" and give the series a try.

The story focuses on New Mexico Gov. Arcadia Alvarado, a popular politician on the cusp of announcing her candidacy for the presidency of the United States. Along the way, however, she and her ex-husband, Michael, are abducted by aliens. The book was described in early reviews as a cross between "The X-Files" and "The West Wing," both shows I enjoy.

But I have to be honest, while I liked the premise of the series, I was undecided about the execution after reading the first six issues included in the first trade, Run. The art isn't bad; Ryan Kelly does a good job illustrating the main characters, keeping their appearances consistent from image to image, and making the more grounded scenes feel like the world we are all familiar with. He also does a good job with the more fantastical elements and the rare scenes where the two are combined to hauntingly creepy effect. And overall, I liked Paul Cornell's story; he is another writer whose work on the iconic company characters hasn't always lined up with my personal tastes, but I can better appreciate his writer's voice on his own original characters.

The problem was not feeling like I really understood the underlying story that was unfolding involving the aliens and the various conspiracy theories that come in and out of the narrative. I wasn't always certain exactly what was happening in some of the more fantastical "remembered" scenes characters would relate after the fact.

Some research into the series told me that there was only one more trade; the series had been cancelled early, presumably due to low sales. Finding out the series had been cancelled early made me worry there would never be any kind of resolution to the Saucer Country tale, but the parts I liked, I liked enough to take a chance on a series I'd already read half of (or so I thought). So I started hunting for the second trade, hopefully at a reasonable price to assuage my uncertainty.

Turns out that second trade, The Reticulan Candidate, collects issues 7-14 of the series, so a little more than half remained. And it continued to be a good read, although I still felt I wasn't always "getting" every scene. And truthfully, every single plot thread is not explained by the end of the series. As in the real world when it comes to alien visitation, some of the questions raised are left hanging, unanswered, leaving both readers and characters questioning. But I'm happy to report that the series does have a satisfying ending, and many answers are provided. Some portions of the tale are explained and finally fleshed out, making it clear that the portions that had left me feeling confused before were deliberately crafted that way. The exact events that transpired were left vague by design, not poor writing or poor comprehension on my part.

I'm glad I took the chance on the second volume of the series, and if the premise sounds even remotely interesting to you, I suggest you pick these two trades up. That's why I'm deliberately keeping my descriptions a little more vague this time out than I usually do. I don't want to ruin anything for the next reader who might also enjoy this series.

None of this is to say that folks who read an issue of a title and drop it because they don't like it should have just stuck with the book and it would have all made sense. This was a happy example where that strategy worked for me, and I'm glad it did. But no one knows your reading likes and dislikes better than you, and if you're not liking a story, you should move on if that is your choice. Life is too short to waste reading anything you're not enjoying.

But maybe, some folks on the Internet who bash a story as incomprehensible after reading only the first part of a four- or six-part story, should reserve judgment a little longer. Give the creators a chance to reveal their full vision before pronouncing something garbage. It would certainly make the web a friendlier, happier place for us all to come together.

What Do You Think You're Doing?

In case the absence of a comic title, issue number and list of creators didn't already clue you in, we aren't talking about a specific book today. I am hopeful that my "new normal" at work becomes just a little more normal soon because I haven't just had trouble finding time to write posts for the ol' Comics Blog, I haven't had a lot of time to READ either! I have some comics and trades than were released and delivered back in July that I haven't read yet.

Of course, just because I haven't had a lot of time to actually read any of my comics, doesn't mean I don't still have some time to think about comics. I mean, c'mon, I can't be expected to think about work ALL the time I'm at work, can I? (None of my bosses from work read this, right?)

Anyway, in the absence of being able to actually read my comics, I've still been doing some thinking about my comics habit, and I've come to a bit of a realization coinciding with my efforts to winnow down what I buy each month, which also coincides with my efforts to drastically reduce the size of my comics collection by selling off a bunch of what I have amassed.

If you had asked me any time over, let's say the past 25 to 30 years, I would have readily told you that I collected comics. That was my mentality at the time, and I stand by that statement on the surface of it. I was buying what I was reading, and for the most part, I was reading what I was enjoying. I was a comics reader and collector.

And I still see myself as a collector, even though I am trying to sell off a bunch of my comics. I've just refined my focus a bit. I have three main characters — Aquaman, Nightwing and Green Arrow — I have followed for a long time, continue to follow now, and plan to continue to follow into the future. Then there are characters from other media I like whose occasional forays into comics I will likely continue to have an interest in — the original Star Trek crew, the Lone Ranger, Zorro, to name just a few. And there are more titles that I like to read and enjoy, holding onto certain issues, runs and titles that for whatever reason seem to resonate just a little bit more with me.

But thinking about the differences in my buying habits between then and now, I've noticed that the main difference is in that refined focus now. Then, I was mostly focused on amassing a huge collection of a variety of titles and genres of comics. I was much less discriminating in what I bought, following a larger number of characters and titles and creators, amassing a huge collection of books that made me feel good in the immediate moment. And they did make me feel good, because again, I was buying what I was reading and reading what I was enjoying. But it was more about a goal of having the books as there were so many of them, there wasn't a lot of time to go back and re-read favorites. In fact, there were several titles I bought that I certainly planned to read as soon as possible, but set aside in favor of reading more immediate story lines. That pile of things to read "sometime" just kept getting bigger and bigger.

It was mostly about amassing the collection, although I don't think I ever thought of it in those terms then. Trying to decide what to keep and what to sell hasn't been about getting rid of comics I don't like; I always did that along the way. If I tried a book and didn't care for it, I stopped buying it and got rid of what I had, hopefully to someone who could better appreciate it. This culling process I've been going through — and continue to go through — is more about winnowing down the collection to the most prized books and stories, keeping the size managable and allowing myself time to re-read and re-enjoy favorite arcs and stories.

I'm not trying to belittle or denigrate anyone else's buying or collecting habits. Even amassing lots of comics is a type of collecting. For me personally, I feel that I am better appreciating what I am keeping by narrowing the focus of my collection so I am amassing a smaller number of specific things. It's certainly a more practical collection.

Let's hear from some of you: What is comic collecting to you and what do you collect — characters, titles, creators or anything and everything?

**********

Switching gears for a moment, I have some auctions running on eBay this week for anyone interested in the stuff I'm selling off. Depending on what you enjoy, you might find some good deals among the auctions. And of course, the most complete, up-to-date list of what I have available for sale or trade can be found at the main Steve's Comics For Sale site.

Do You Ever Get That Sinking Feeling?

Lois & Clark: A Superman Novel
Prima Publishing
C.J. Cherryh, writer

I was a fan of the Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman television program in the 90s. It isn't the best example of superheroes being done in a live-action format, and the show seemed somewhat dated when I re-watched the first season a few years ago. But it was an interesting prime-time glimpse into the relationship between these two iconic characters, and it was a fun — albeit down-to-earth — portrayal of the Superman mythos.

I say down-to-earth because the budget constraints of a weekly network television program from 20ish years ago didn't allow for a lot of powerful adversaries for Superman to face. Other than Superman's own, I don't think a single other costume appeared in the series. While a few names of super-powered rogues were re-imagined in the series, no costumed villains were in evidence in that version of Metropolis. In fact, I think the only time Superman faced a powered threat in the series was in the fourth season when some other Kryptonians showed up on earth. But all of that grounded adventure helped keep the show's focus on the relationship between Lois Lane and Clark Kent, Superman's alter ego. That's who the show was named for, and those two were the show's stated focus.

This novel, based of the television show's continuity and published in 1996, follows the same formula of no super-powered threats for the Man of Steel, taking the main focus off superheroics and placing it on the relationship between The Daily Planet's two star reporters. That being said, this is a very well-done original Superman novel that also gives some nice insights into the Man of Steel, his powers, his goals and his limitations.

The big threat facing Superman in the book is an earthquake which causes a poorly-constructed dam to fail, threatening several villages and rural farmers in one of the former Soviet republics. I can't tell you the number of times I've seen Superman tackle a natural disaster in a mere matter of moments in comic stories and animation. A volcano is threatening a Pacific island population? A giant boulder quickly caps the threat or a blast of super-cooled breath hardens the boiling lava. An earthquake shakes a major city somewhere? Superman just burrows underground at super-speed, relieving the pressures. Dam breaks? A quick shot of heat vision welds it back into one piece.

Not so in this book. Modern technology has indicated the likely threat of an impending earthquake somewhere in the region. Learning of this, Clark Kent has been keeping an eye on The Daily Planet's wire services reports coming out of the area for signs of danger for the past week. That's one of the reasons the young Clark Kent decided to become a reporter — to have news resources and be able to monitor situations around the globe.

Even Superman can't be an expert on everything. So Clark has spent some of his downtime during that previous week, studying maps of the area, familiarizing himself with locations of towns and villages, lakes and rivers that might be affected if a quake should happen. He also studies up on the politics of the region so he will better be prepared to work with whatever local governments and/or relief agencies might be involved wherever disaster might strike. But also, this advance research helps Superman know where he is going. Flying across Metropolis, a city he is already familiar with, might not be much of a challenge; but flying from the eastern United States to a country on the other side of the globe that he's never been to before might present some difficulties if Superman weren't prepared. Borders and landmarks clearly detailed on a map don't show up on real terrain.

All of this is a nice touch in the book to keep things a little more grounded, again, like the show, and unlike a more traditional Superman story. It's to the point where even in a few instances where Superman can fall back on some of those more familiar remedies, there's a complicated real-world twist I've never thought of before. For instance, at one point Superman is able to use his heat vision to weld back together the fracturing support on a bridge damaged in the quake. But he must use a delicate balance of his heat vision with his super breath because the damage is underwater. Using his heat vision alone would also boil the surrounding water, destroying much of the fish and plant life in the river. He must use extra care to heat up the damaged bridge support, yet keep the surrounding water temperature normal. It makes him more of a thinking character than one of sheer brute force, and I like that.

So Superman sets about trying to minimize the damage from the quake and the failing dam, flying trapped residents to safety, protecting the survivors from nearby guerrilla fighters, and coordinating efforts between governments and relief agencies, all while maintaining his secret identity and trying to restore things to their previous condition where possible after the quake.

Of course, Clark/Superman is only half the subject of this book. After the Man of Steel flies off to help with the quake, disaster also strikes in Metropolis. The residents of the city, including those in The Daily Planet building, are shocked when a downtown hotel collapses. The hotel happens to be only a few blocks away, so reporters and staffers from The Planet are some of the first on the scene, including Lois Lane, who quickly sets about trying to help people caught in the collapse while also trying to determine what has happened to cause the tragedy.

Lois, every bit as resourceful and heroic as her fiance, helps a number of people to safety before becoming a central figure in the rescue efforts of a young boy trapped in an underground parking garage below the hotel. Of course, Lois has to accomplish all she can without the benefit of superpowers, and her efforts take more of a physical toll on her all-too-human body.

Despite her own injuries, once all of the victims who can be saved are rescued from the collapsed hotel, there are still a great many questions to answer about what exactly caused the collapse. Blame begins to center on the contractor who designed the building, but Lois begins to suspect there is more to the story, and proceeds to uncover details which tie into previous continuity of the show going back to the earliest episodes.

While Clark pursues his Superman duties, Lois must act, largely alone, to expose the real threat to Metropolis. But the pair have brief moments here and there to come back together, encouraging and supporting each other through the twin emergencies. That all serves to further showcase the partnership between these two individuals who manage to combine to be a true dynamic duo stronger than either is separately.

Ms. Cherryh has crafted an engaging story that explores these two famous characters in fresh ways while remaining true to the core traits a reader would expect from a Superman and Lois Lane story. If you are a fan of Superman, I encourage you to give this novel a try. And even though the story she presents ties closely into the continuity of the television series, Cherryh provides all of the information necessary to follow and enjoy this self-contained narrative, keeping it accessible to readers not already familiar with the series.